Scholar Evaluation
Evaluate papers, proposals, and literature reviews against a repeatable 9-dimension rubric, with scores, blockers, and concrete revisions.
- What
- Evaluate papers, proposals, and literature reviews against a repeatable 9-dimension rubric, with scores, blockers, and concrete revisions.
- Cost
- Free
- Needs
- Pinned version: install the code at commit 4eb71d92a39cab44ad40ac9d8a6a5ccb4029d6c2 exactly (Skill Harbor tested this version). Do not substitute a newer version. If this commit is unreachable, stop and tell me.
- Level
- Beginner — Pinned version: install the code at commit…
- Install
- Copy the installer prompt below into your Muse — your agent does the rest.
Curated by Skill Harbor: a structured evaluation workflow for academic and scientific work, from the affaan-m/ECC community contributions. Handles empirical and theoretical papers, technical reports, systematic or narrative literature reviews, research proposals, thesis chapters, and conference abstracts. Scores nine dimensions from 1 to 5: problem and research question, literature and context, methodology, data and evidence, analysis, results and interpretation, limitations and threats to validity, writing and structure, and citations. Includes a defined review process (read abstract, introduction, figures, and conclusion first for the claimed contribution; check the strongest claims against cited sources; separate critical blockers from revision suggestions) and a ready output template with dimension scores, evidence, and revision priority. By @affaan-m, listed here with credit to its creator. From the affaan-m/ECC repository (MIT). Honest caveats: a rubric, not peer review; the score is a summary, never a substitute for concrete feedback. Do not penalize a paper for omitting a dimension outside its scope, and do not treat venue or author reputation as proof of quality. Skill Harbor never reviews the code, review it yourself before use.
Version:
Quick answer
Scholar Evaluation is a free skill for Muse. a structured evaluation workflow for academic and scientific work, from the affaan-m/ECC community contributions. Handles empirical and theoretical papers, technical reports, systematic or narrative literature reviews, research proposals, thesis chapters, and conference abstracts.
Install
Copy the install package below, then paste it into Muse🧪 Install ran in our test sandbox · Nov 11, 2026📌 Pinned version: commit 4eb71d9Pinned version: install the code at commit 4eb71d92a39cab44ad40ac9d8a6a5ccb4029d6c2 exactly (Skill Harbor tested this version). Do not substitute a newer version. If this commit is unreachable, stop and tell me. Use "Scholar Evaluation" with your Muse. 1. Open the skill: https://raw.githubusercontent.com/affaan-m/ECC/4eb71d92a39cab44ad40ac9d8a6a5ccb4029d6c2/skills/scientific-thinking-scholar-evaluation/SKILL.md and copy the full SKILL.md text. 2. Paste it into a chat with Muse and add: "Evaluate this paper against the rubric: [paste abstract or link]" or "Compare these two proposals on methodology and evidence: [paste]." 3. Choose the scope first: comprehensive, targeted (one or two dimensions), or comparative. Tip: use the score table as a map, not a verdict; the critical issues and recommended revisions sections carry the real value. Safety: a skill is plain-text instructions; it runs nothing by itself. Keep unpublished manuscripts out of any chat unless you have the right to share them.
Saved to your recent installs. Find it anytime on /connect.
🔒 Security, provenance and what this touches
The install prompt below already includes the vetting steps: your agent follows the community checklist before installing anything with executable code. Want more?
Verification certificate
Dated facts about what was checked for this listing, and how. This is not a safety certification.
- Pinned version
- 4eb71d9 · 2026-10-13
- Sandbox install test
- Install ran in our test sandbox · Nov 11, 2026
- Creator identity
- Not verified
- Fingerprint watch
- Last checked · Nov 21, 2026 : no change detected in the files linked by this install prompt
- Install prompt analysis
- 2026-10-13 : No commands, network calls, packages, file writes or API keys detected.
Skill Harbor never reviews the code of a listed skill. These are dated facts about the install prompt and our install test, not a safety certification. Review a skill yourself before you install it. How we verify
Questions
How do I install a skill?
Every product page includes a copy-paste install prompt. Paste it into your Muse and it sets the skill up for you — no manual configuration.
Where does my money go?
Straight to the seller. Skill Harbor never processes payments: checkout happens on the seller’s own page, usually Stripe.
What does the ✓ next to a creator’s name mean?
It means we confirmed the identity of the person behind the listing. It says nothing about the code itself — always check a skill before installing it.